Elise van Nederveen Meerkerk and Daniëlle Teeuwen, ‘The Stability of Voluntarism. Financing Social Care in Early Modern Dutch Towns Compared with the English Poor Law, c. 1600-1800’, European Review of Economic History 18:1 (2014) 82-105.
This article aims to compare the financing of two apparently entirely different systems of pre-industrial welfare: urban institutional welfare in the federal Dutch Republic and the national Elizabethan Poor Law in Britain. By analysing a new dataset on the income and expenditure of five Dutch towns, we conclude that, despite the absence of uniform legislation, Dutch poor relief was viable at least up until the 1790s, even in times of severe crises and declining real wages. This was obtained by the – in monetary terms – remarkably stable donations by Dutch citizens, mostly through regular collections, as well as careful financial management of the charitable funds.